The Ninth Circuit recently reiterated that plaintiffs seeking class certification cannot show damages are susceptible to common proof by “[m]erely gesturing” at a damages model or “describing a general method” of calculating damages. That reminder comes from Heagney v. John Paul Mitchell Systems, No. 25-6818, 2026 WL 3017602 (9th
Continue Reading Ninth Circuit Vacates Class Certification Based on Insufficiently Reliable Damages ModelClass Action Procedure
Global-Market Price-Fixing Theory in Concrete Admixtures Class Action Rejected Under the FTAIA
In In re Concrete and Cement Additives Antitrust Litigation, the District Court for the Southern District of New York recently dismissed with prejudice claims brought by a proposed class of construction companies and concrete distributors against the world’s largest producers of concrete and cement additives (“CCAs”). The class complaint…
Continue Reading Global-Market Price-Fixing Theory in Concrete Admixtures Class Action Rejected Under the FTAIAN.D. Cal. Rejects Non-Specific Tolling Arguments in Shah v. Politico LLC
In Shah v. Politico LLC, 5:25-cv-05213 (N.D. Cal. Sept. 25, 2026), the Court addressed plaintiffs’ attempts to invoke equitable tolling, delayed discovery, and fraudulent concealment to save untimely claims under the California Invasion of Privacy Act (“CIPA”).
Defendant Politico LLC (“Politico”) had filed a motion to dismiss allegations…
Continue Reading N.D. Cal. Rejects Non-Specific Tolling Arguments in Shah v. Politico LLCPixel Tracking Technologies and Article III Standing: Lessons from the Rack Room Shoes Decision
In Smith v. Rack Room Shoes, Inc., No. 24-cv-06709-RFL (N.D. Cal. Sept. 21, 2026), Plaintiffs sought class certification on claims under the California Invasion of Privacy Act, Cal. Penal Code §§ 631 and 632, and the Federal Wiretap Act, 18 U.S.C. § 2511(1)(a). Plaintiffs asserted that Defendant Rack Room, an online shoe retailer, helped third-party pixel-tracking services intercept private communications containing personally identifiable information. The Court found that Plaintiffs had no Article III standing, rejecting harm theories based on both actual and attempted interception of private information, and dismissed those claims without prejudice while denying class certification.
Continue Reading Pixel Tracking Technologies and Article III Standing: Lessons from the Rack Room Shoes DecisionNinth Circuit Emphasizes Importance of Connecting Visual Proof to Class Members for Motions to Compel Arbitration
A recent Ninth Circuit decision, Rushing v. Williams-Sonoma, Inc., 2026 WL 2731408 (9th Cir. Sept. 16, 2026), confirms that defendants seeking to compel arbitration based on internet contracts must do more than submit exemplar screenshots of webpages containing arbitration-related disclosures. Rather, to meet their evidentiary burden, defendants must tie that visual evidence to the specific users at issue—showing that the webpages actually appeared as depicted in the exemplars at the time those users accessed them.
In Rushing, the plaintiffs brought a putative class action alleging false advertising related to the thread count of defendants’ bedding products. After the district court certified a class of California consumers, the defendants moved to compel arbitration of claims by class members who had purportedly agreed to defendants’ arbitration agreement. In support, defendants submitted declarations and accompanying exemplar screenshots of checkout and account sign-up processes on their webpages that contained language disclosing that taking some action on the page constituted agreement to defendants’ terms and conditions, which included an arbitration agreement.
Continue Reading Ninth Circuit Emphasizes Importance of Connecting Visual Proof to Class Members for Motions to Compel ArbitrationPreserving the Right to Arbitrate Against Unnamed Class Members
Does class certification strip a defendant of its right to compel arbitration against unnamed class members? The Third Circuit recently held that it does not, unless the party seeking arbitration has waived that right by expressly or impliedly demonstrating an intentional relinquishment or abandonment of it. Salvatora v. XTO Energy, Inc., ___ F.4th ___, *3 (3d Cir. 2026). What, then, constitutes such a demonstration?
Continue Reading Preserving the Right to Arbitrate Against Unnamed Class MembersNo Misfire, No Case: Eighth Circuit Decertifies Gun-Defect Class Action Over Standing
Owning a product that might malfunction isn’t enough for Article III standing—the defect must actually manifest. That’s the message from Glasscock v. Sig Sauer, Inc., __ F.4th __, 2026 WL 2054200 (8th Cir. July 16, 2026), where the Eighth Circuit vacated class certification and dismissed the case after the named plaintiff admitted his firearm had never malfunctioned.
Continue Reading No Misfire, No Case: Eighth Circuit Decertifies Gun-Defect Class Action Over StandingNon-Statistical Evidence in No-Poach Antitrust Litigation Not Enough to Certify Class, Says Illinois Court
In In re Outpatient Medical Center Employee Antitrust Litigation, 2026 WL 1678954,the Northern District of Illinois recently refused to certify a proposed class of healthcare employees who alleged that their employers entered into a “no-poach agreement” that prohibited them from recruiting each other’s senior-level personnel and thereby suppressed compensation for all employees with similar qualifications. After excluding the plaintiffs’ expert’s statistical analysis of employee compensation under Rule 702, the Court determined that plaintiffs’ remaining non-statistical evidence did not show common proof of classwide antitrust impact.
Continue Reading Non-Statistical Evidence in No-Poach Antitrust Litigation Not Enough to Certify Class, Says Illinois CourtStand Aside: Third Circuit Throws Out Harriet Carter Gifts Federal Wiretapping Case On Standing Grounds
We have routinely highlighted the proliferation of wiretapping class actions, and the variety of approaches courts have taken to address them. One common pitfall for plaintiffs in these types of cases is standing, an issue highlighted in a recent Third Circuit case throwing out a proposed federal class action against Harriet Carter Gifts and NaviStone Inc., and remanding it to state court.
The case, Popa v. Harriet Carter Gifts, Inc., No. 25-1760 (3d. Cir. 2026), involved plaintiff’s allegations that Harriet Carter Gifts and NaviStone tracked her browsing activity on Harriet Carter’s website while she shopped for pet stairs, purportedly in violation of the Pennsylvania Wiretapping and Electronic Surveillance Control Act. After removal, the district court twice granted summary judgment for the defendants, and both decisions were appealed to the Third Circuit.
Continue Reading Stand Aside: Third Circuit Throws Out Harriet Carter Gifts Federal Wiretapping Case On Standing GroundsFederal Circuit Agrees with Majority View on Class Representative Incentive Awards
We previously covered the Eleventh Circuit’s decision to deny rehearing in Johnson v. NPAS Solutions, LLC, 2022 WL 3083717 (11th Cir. Aug. 3, 2022), which had held that district courts may not approve incentive awards for class representatives in class action settlements. Since that time, we have also covered decisions from other courts (including the Seventh Circuit) which declined to follow the Eleventh Circuit, leaving that court standing alone in barring incentive awards. The Federal Circuit has now also declined to follow the Eleventh Circuit’s minority view.
Continue Reading Federal Circuit Agrees with Majority View on Class Representative Incentive Awards