The First Circuit recently vacated and remanded a district court’s approval of a proposed class action settlement “because the absence of separate settlement counsel for distinct groups of class members makes it too difficult to determine whether the settlement treated class members equitably.” Murray v. Grocery Deliver E-Servs. USA Inc., — F.4th —, 2022 WL 17729630, at *1 (1st Cir. Dec. 16, 2022). At the same time, the First Circuit declined to follow the Eleventh Circuit’s recent decision banning incentive awards to class representatives.

On October 15, 2021, a district court approved a class action settlement resolving plaintiffs’ claims that defendant HelloFresh violated the Telephone Consumer Protection Act in three different ways. On appeal, an objector argued that the settlement was defective because class members with one type of claim had stronger and more valuable claims than members with the two other claims, so it was inadequate for class members with different claims to be represented by the same counsel during settlement negotiations.

The First Circuit agreed. Because the same counsel represented different groups of plaintiffs whose claims involved “significantly different elements” and faced “very different defenses,” the First Circuit found that the “district court lacked the requisite basis for certifying the settlement class and approving the allocation of the $14 million among class members as fair, reasonable, and adequate.” Id. at *8. The Court explained that if the same counsel represents groups of plaintiffs “with significantly different claims in the context of allocating a lump-sum settlement,” then the district court “lacks structural assurance that the settlement treats each group fairly.” Id. at *4. In Murray, for instance, the class members’ three TCPA claims involved different elements and defenses that were “too significant to leave the equitable apportionment of a common fund to a court’s discretion” without the procedural safeguard of an “arm’s-length negotiation between separately represented groups” to ensure that class counsel was not “selling out” one category of claim for another. Id. at *4–8.

In the process, the Court rejected the objector’s arguments that incentive awards for named plaintiffs are improper. Although the Eleventh Circuit recently made waves for holding that class settlements may not offer incentive awards to class representatives, the First Circuit chose “to follow the collective wisdom of courts over the past several decades that have permitted these sorts of incentive payments, rather than create a categorical rule that refuses to consider the facts of each case.” Id. at *10. The Court also rejected the objector’s argument that incentive awards categorically present a conflict of interest that prevents named plaintiffs from adequately representing the class. See id.

The First Circuit’s decision should remind companies who are negotiating a proposed class settlement to consider whether separate counsel is necessary to represent groups of plaintiffs that have significantly different claims—i.e., claims with materially different elements or defenses. Moreover, although the Court did not address the extent to which a class may be certified for litigation, see id. at *8 n.1, it noted that “much, if not all, of [its] analysis would apply to Rule 23(a)’s adequate representation requirement in the context of class certification for settlement,” id. at *3. Thus, defendants may be able to apply the Court’s reasoning to argue that a class should not be certified under Rule 23(a)(4)’s adequacy requirement if a single class counsel represents plaintiffs who have claims that involve significantly different elements or defenses.

Print:
Email this postTweet this postLike this postShare this post on LinkedIn
Photo of Stephen Rees Stephen Rees

Stephen Rees is a litigation associate in the firm’s Washington, DC office. He has handled matters involving a range of issues, including class actions, antitrust, product liability, consumer fraud, breach of contract, tort, ERISA, and insurance claims.

Stephen has experience in all stages…

Stephen Rees is a litigation associate in the firm’s Washington, DC office. He has handled matters involving a range of issues, including class actions, antitrust, product liability, consumer fraud, breach of contract, tort, ERISA, and insurance claims.

Stephen has experience in all stages of litigation, including:

dispositive motions;
fact and expert discovery;
class certification;
summary judgment;
mediation;
arbitration; and
trial preparation

Stephen has first-chaired fact witness depositions, drafted dispositive motions in both federal and state court, and argued in federal district and appellate courts. In addition, he maintains an active pro bono practice, with an emphasis on immigration-related impact litigation and criminal law matters.

Photo of Andrew Soukup Andrew Soukup

Andrew Soukup serves as co-chair of the firm’s Class Action Litigation Practice Group. He specializes in representing heavily regulated businesses in class actions, multidistrict litigation, and other high-stakes disputes.

Praised for “big wins in his class action practice,” Andrew has defeated advertising, consumer…

Andrew Soukup serves as co-chair of the firm’s Class Action Litigation Practice Group. He specializes in representing heavily regulated businesses in class actions, multidistrict litigation, and other high-stakes disputes.

Praised for “big wins in his class action practice,” Andrew has defeated advertising, consumer protection, privacy, and product defect and safety claims with exposure ranging from millions to billions of dollars. His “proven record” has earned Andrew recognition as an “attorney you want on your side in a bet-the-company case.” Clients trust Andrew with their most important matters—whether he is leading a defense from the first filing or stepping in midstream with a fresh perspective.

Andrew represents clients in the consumer products, life sciences, financial services, technology, transportation, gaming, and media and communications industries. He has consistently prevailed in litigation in federal and state courts across the country against putative class representatives, government agencies, state attorneys general, and commercial entities.

Drawing on a long history of representing companies subject to extensive federal regulation and oversight, Andrew has a unique ability to help courts understand the complex environment that governs his clients’ businesses. He has earned praise for “understanding the big picture, the strategic vision of the individual case, and how that fits into the broader business strategy of the client.” Clients trust Andrew because of his successful outcomes at every stage of litigation, his responsiveness and attention to their matters, and his deep understanding of their businesses.

Andrew’s recent successes include:

Successfully defending several of the world’s leading companies and brands against class actions accusing them of engaging in deceptive marketing or selling defective products, including claims under state consumer protection and unfair and deceptive acts or practices statutes.
Defeating class certification in a privacy class action against one of the nation’s leading financial institutions.
Defeating industry-wide, multidistrict class-action claims against one of the nation’s leading consumer products companies challenging its marketing of over-the-counter medicine containing allegedly ineffective ingredients—a win that earned Andrew recognition by American Lawyer as a “Litigator of the Week.”
Delivering wins in multiple nationwide class actions for leading financial institutions over fees, disclosures, and other banking practices—including defending several institutions accused of violating the Paycheck Protection Program’s implementing laws, work that contributed to Covington’s recognition as a “Class Action Group of the Year.”
Representing multiple consumer product and life sciences companies against lawsuits seeking economic damages from the sale of products that allegedly caused personal injuries.
Defending several of the world’s most prominent companies against ESG-related claims accusing them of misrepresenting their practices.

Andrew has also achieved favorable outcomes navigating commercial and indemnification disputes between clients and their business partners involving contracts, fraud, and other business torts. He advises on arbitration agreements, has helped numerous clients avoid multidistrict and class-action litigation by enforcing them, and guides companies through mass arbitrations.

A recognized thought leader on class-action issues, Andrew regularly contributes to the firm’s blog, Inside Class Actions. He has been named a Lawyer of the Week by The American Lawyer, included on the Daily Journal’s list of Leading Commercial Litigators (2025), and ranked as a leading litigator by Chambers USA.

Watch: Andrew shares insights on class action litigation, as part of our Navigating Class Actions video series.