Banks, lenders, and other financial institutions who submit information to credit reporting agencies should take note of a recent Third Circuit decision adopting a “reasonable reader” standard for evaluating whether a credit report was inaccurate or misleading under Fair Credit Reporting Act (“FCRA”).

In Bibbs v. Trans Union LLC, 43 F.4th 331 (3d Cir. 2022), the court considered whether a negative pay status notation reporting that an account was “120 Days Past Due Date” was misleading in violation of the FCRA.  The notation corresponded to student loan accounts that had been closed following nonpayment by the borrowers.  After the accounts were closed, their balances went to zero, and the borrowers’ payment obligations were transferred.   

The borrowers argued this was misleading because an unsophisticated individual could erroneously assume that they were currently more than 120 days late on a loan.  The court agreed that “creditor” as defined by the FCRA “broadly encompasses both sophisticated and unsophisticated individuals and entities alike” and held that courts must apply a reasonable reader—rather than creditor—standard to evaluate whether the report is misleading.  But it rejected Appellant’s “myopic” reading of the negative pay status notation, and held that courts must apply the standard “by reading the entry not in isolation, but rather by reading the report in its entirety.” After applying this standard, the court determined that even if the entry read in isolation could lead a reader to believe the account was currently past due, the rest of the report clearly showed that the loan was closed.  For example, the report stated “ACCT CLOSED DUE TO TRANSFER; TRANSFERRED TO ANOTHER OFFICE” and reported the “Date Closed:” was “04/05/2018.”  The court affirmed the district court’s ruling that the credit reports were accurate under §1681e(b).

Print:
Email this postTweet this postLike this postShare this post on LinkedIn
Photo of Marianne Spencer Marianne Spencer

Marianne Spencer represents companies in high-stakes litigation in state and federal courts nationwide. Her practice focuses on class actions and complex commercial disputes, with particular depth in defending clients against privacy lawsuits arising from emerging technologies.

Marianne represents clients across the full lifecycle…

Marianne Spencer represents companies in high-stakes litigation in state and federal courts nationwide. Her practice focuses on class actions and complex commercial disputes, with particular depth in defending clients against privacy lawsuits arising from emerging technologies.

Marianne represents clients across the full lifecycle of a dispute—from pre-suit counseling through appeal—and has a strong track record at each phase. Recent successes include defeating class certification in a billion-dollar privacy class action and securing a complete victory for a financial services client facing tens of millions of dollars in potential exposure. She has achieved favorable results for clients in the financial services, technology, pharmaceutical, and sports industries at all stages of litigation, including by securing early dismissals, winning summary judgment, and defeating class certification.

Before joining the firm, Marianne served as a law clerk to the Honorable Steven M. Colloton of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit. She maintains an active pro bono practice focused on civil rights, housing, and immigration.